Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Upper West Side

Upper West Side Menu
Upper West Side location

Hours & Location

426 Amsterdam Ave,
New York, NY
212.877.8800

Open Daily: 12pm - 8:00pm

Order Online

About

Working directly with fishermen allows us to bring you the world's best-tasting seafood, cooked to perfection and prepared simply. All of our lobster, shrimp, and crab rolls are sustainably sourced and served in a split-top New England-style bun with a swipe of mayo, lemon butter, and our secret seasoning. Stop by and try one of our signature rolls today, or make it a jumbo roll with 50% more seafood! 

Looking to try something different for your next date night in? Click "Order Online" and have dinner delivered to your door! Ordering for a group? Let us cater your next event.

Luke’s Upper West Side, our third location has stool-seating for 18 and outdoor seating for 6 (weather permitting.) Stop by for Happy Hour!

Get Directions

Menus

All of our rolls are served with 4 oz (1/4 lb) or 6 oz chilled, wild-caught lobster, crab, or shrimp in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo, lemon butter, and our seasoning--the way Luke grew up eating them in Maine. We source directly from fishermen we know and trust in an industry Luke's family has been part of for three generations. We've perfected the craft of steaming and picking in our own production company in Maine, and bring it direct to you in pristine form.

The Rolls

All of our rolls are served with 4oz or 6oz of chilled, wild-caught lobster, crab, or shrimp in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo, lemon butter, and our seasoning.

  • Lobster Roll (4oz/6oz)

    $17 - $23 (300 - 380 cal.)

  • Crab roll (4oz/6oz)

    $14 - $19 (310 - 390 cal.)

  • Shrimp Roll (4oz/6oz)

    $10 - $14 (310 - 390 cal.)

  • Luke's Trio

    (1/2 lobster roll, 1/2 crab roll, and 1/2 shrimp roll)

    $20 (460 cal.)

Make your Roll a Combo!

  • add chips + drink

    $2 (375 cal.)

  • add slaw + drink

    $3 (205 cal.)

  • add chowder + drink

    $8 - $11 (425 cal.)

  • add bisque + drink

    $10 - $13 (485 cal.)

  • add lobster mac and cheese + drink

    $13 (585 cal.)

  • Upgrade your drink for a beer!

Winter at Luke's

  • Spicy Honey Butter Lobster Roll

    w/ melted Mike's Hot Honey - Extra Hot butter and aleppo pepper flakes

    $19 - $25 (300 - 380 cal.)

  • Truffle Lobster Roll

    w/ melted white truffle butter & chips

    $19 - $25 (310 - 390 cal.)

  • Lobster Grilled Cheese

    $14 (540 cal.)

  • Crab Grilled Cheese

    $11 (540 cal.)

Luke's at Home

  • DIY Kits

    Everything you need to make 2 lobster rolls at home.

    $34 (600 - 670 cal.)

  • Seafood by the Pound

    Ask about lobster, crab, & shrimp by the pound for dinner at home!

For the Whole Fam

  • 4 Lobster Rolls w/ Chips + Slaw

    $70 - $90 (2080 cal.)

    add 4-pack Allagash white $15

    add 4-pack soda $10

    add qt of chowder (1040 cal) $22

    add qt of bisque $32

Soups

8oz/12oz/32oz

  • N.E. Clam Chowder

    $7 - $26 (260 - 1041 cal.)

  • Lobster Bisque

    $9 - $34 (320 - 1280 cal.)

Sides & Drinks

  • Lobster Mac & cheese

    $12 (480 cal.)

  • Poppyseed slaw

    $3 (40 cal.)

  • Kettle chips

    $2 (210 cal.)

  • Soft drinks

    $3 (5 - 165 cal.)

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!